Back to Blogs
Blog Img

Is the BBC Missing the Mark on Diversity? A Debate on Inclusion vs. Education.

The BBC is under scrutiny for its directive instructing staff not to hire candidates perceived as "dismissive" of diversity and inclusion. While their commitment to an inclusive workplace is evident, questions arise regarding potential ramifications and whether the organization is missing an opportunity for transformative education.

Here's some context, The Telegraph revealed that BBC staff are being told not to hire candidates who are “dismissive” of diversity and inclusion.

Recent statistics highlight persistent challenges in achieving diversity and inclusion. According to a 2023 McKinsey report, companies in the top quartile for ethnic diversity are 36% more likely to outperform counterparts in profitability. The BBC's recruitment policy mandates applicants to express commitment to diversity, potentially excluding individuals whose perspectives could evolve through education.

Rather than outright rejection, an alternative approach involves coupling stringent hiring policies with internal education programs on equity, diversity and inclusion (EDI). Recent trends show positive impacts of such training, with a Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) study revealing a 72% increase in employee satisfaction and a 60% increase in team collaboration in companies with comprehensive EDI training programs.

Balancing a diverse workplace with educational initiatives is crucial. While setting standards for inclusive values is important, the BBC can enhance impact by providing internal training programs. These can bridge gaps in understanding, transforming individuals into advocates for diversity.

Initiatives in other industries emphasize success with a combined approach. Companies focusing on both hiring policies and internal EDI training witness improvements in workplace culture, employee engagement, and overall performance.

The BBC's commitment is commendable, but the current directive prompts reflection. Integrating stringent policies with comprehensive internal education can eliminate dismissive attitudes and position the organization as a leader in fostering a genuinely inclusive culture. Embracing this holistic approach is not only beneficial for the BBC but also contributes to a broader societal shift towards genuine diversity and inclusion.


If you want to talk about how you can improve your diversity and inclusion education within your business. Pleasae reach out